top of page

Classification: where you draw the line decides who's "us" and who's "them"

Writer: Kat Greenbrook
Kat Greenbrook
4 days ago
6 min read

"We're being flooded with immigrants." Versions of this sentiment come up in political debate. Someone even told me it was the reason they voted.


The saying sorts people into two groups: immigrants, who are "them", and New Zealanders, who are "us".


But what makes someone an immigrant?


The answer depends on how people are classified.



What is classification?


We sort data about people into categories, such as visa type. Each category is split into groups, such as student, work, visitor, and residence visas. Groups let us count people and compare them. In law, they decide what people get, such as who can work in Aotearoa.


The groups, and where the lines sit between them, make up a classification. Those lines are usually drawn by someone in a statistics agency or government.


Let's look at migration. A migrant is anyone who moves from one country to live in another. To the country they leave, they're an emigrant. To the country they arrive in, they're an immigrant. So, the same person is both, depending on which country is counting. Yet we talk a lot about immigrants, and much less about emigrants.


There's no single definition of an immigrant. New Zealand immigration law applies to people who aren't citizens. Stats NZ counts migrant arrivals as anyone who arrives and stays for a year or more, including New Zealand citizens coming home. Others go by birthplace. The UN, for example, counts everyone born overseas as an immigrant, even if they've become a citizen. Someone born in the UK who has lived here for 30 years and become a citizen is an immigrant by one of those definitions, and not by the others. So, are they "us" or are they "them"?



Who counts as "us"?


Stats NZ groups arrivals by the visa people held, or by their citizenship if they didn't need one.


Who's inside New Zealand's migration numbers

Migrant arrivals by visa type or citizenship, departures, and net migration (year to September 2026)

Waterfall chart of New Zealand migration, year to September 2026. Arrivals by group: work visas 33,521, student visas 31,010, New Zealand citizens 26,658, visitor visas 23,159, residence visas 16,074, Australian citizens 4,834, other visas 852. Departures: 113,498. Net migration: 22,611.

Net migration is the number of people who arrived, minus the number who left. In the year to September 2026, about 136,000 people arrived and 113,000 left, so net migration was about 22,600 people. New Zealand citizens made up one in five arrivals and more than half of those who left.


Counted this way, the UK-born citizen who has lived here for 30 years isn't an immigrant, because they arrived too long ago to be included. A New Zealand citizen coming home after a year in Sydney is.


But if people are instead classified by where they were born, anyone born overseas counts as an immigrant, however long they've lived here. That's more than one in four people living in Aotearoa, including the UK-born citizen. By the same measure, it's estimated about 915,000 people born in Aotearoa now live abroad. So, many of "us" were once "them", and many of "us" are now someone else's "them".



Who gets seen as an immigrant?


Calling someone an immigrant can be a neutral description. But it's also tied to nationalism: the idea of who belongs to the nation. In everyday use, the word tends to mean someone seen as different from "us". It can be used to portray a group as lesser, or as a problem. In sociology, this is called othering. One group, usually the one with more power, treats another as less than full members of society: "them".


The metaphor "flooded" does this. It describes people as water: something uncontrollable to hold back. It lumps students, workers, families, refugees, and returning New Zealanders together, and casts "them" as a threat to "us".


Who gets cast as "them" is often racialised. In Aotearoa, people can be judged as immigrants by how they look, a bit like a proxy variable. Attitudes follow the same pattern. In a 2021 government survey, New Zealanders felt more positive about migrants from the United Kingdom (59%) than from India or China (46%).


So, nationalism decides who belongs to the nation, and racialisation decides who looks like they belong.



Who draws the classification line?


Ideas about who belongs end up in law. Some laws protect people: being classified as a refugee, for example, gives someone the right to protection. Others write othering into law.


There's an irony here. The European settlers who arrived after Te Tiriti was signed in 1840 were immigrants too. But through colonisation, they gave themselves the power to decide who "us" was. They then wrote laws that determined who else belonged, with Māori, as tangata whenua, given little say.


  • In 1881, the Chinese Immigrants Act charged every person of Chinese descent arriving a poll tax. From 1908 to 1952, Chinese migrants living in Aotearoa could no longer become citizens, however long they'd been here.


  • In 1920, the Immigration Restriction Amendment Act required every person not "of British birth and parentage" to get a permit before arriving. The Prime Minister said it reflected the wish of most New Zealanders for a white New Zealand. This law stayed in place until 1965.


Today's rules sort people by citizenship. Young UK citizens can come on a working holiday for up to three years, with up to 15,000 places a year. By comparison, young Indian citizens will be able to come for up to 12 months, with 1,000 places a year. Britain's easier path rests on ties that date back to the settlers.


Citizenship itself can be given and taken away. Sāmoans born between 1924 and 1948, while New Zealand governed Sāmoa, were New Zealand citizens. In 1982, Parliament took that away. In 2024, it gave it back. In those 42 years, the people stayed the same, and the law changed twice.



When the line moves, so does the data


People will disagree about how many migrants Aotearoa should welcome, and from where. Whichever side they take, the groups they're arguing about aren't fixed. Classifications are human judgements, and the numbers reflect them.


Sometimes the line moves because our values change. Before 2006, being born in New Zealand made someone a citizen. Now, at least one parent must be a citizen or permanent resident. Some children born here who would once have been citizens now aren’t.


Sometimes the line moves for practical reasons. In 2018, Stats NZ stopped counting migrants by how long they said they'd stay, and started tracking how long they actually stayed. The new rule is more accurate, and it changed the numbers: Stats NZ revised its net migration figures for earlier years, in some years by thousands of people.



What to do about it


  1. Name who drew the line between groups. In the note under a chart or table, say which definition of immigrant or migrant you've used, and who set it, such as Stats NZ. This shows that people decided who was included in the group.


  2. Show if the line moved. If a classification changed during the period you're showing, like the 2018 change to how migrants are counted, add a note or a line on the chart at that point. Readers can then tell a change in the rules from a change in people's movement.


  3. Show who's inside the numbers. Treating immigrants as one group invites an "us" against "them" comparison, and readers fill it with whoever they picture. That picture is often racialised. Instead, break arrivals down, like the chart above.


  4. Watch the metaphors. Metaphors shape how people understand what's happening, and which responses seem reasonable. Swap "flooded" or "surge" for what actually happened: "arrivals increased", or "net migration was about 22,600 people".



Every bar in a migration chart is made of people: students, carers, parents, citizens coming home. The groups you show decide whether your readers see them, or a flood.





Published 13 November 2026

I write about data and power, so if you'd like to follow along, the best place to do that is my newsletter. This article is part of the Things We Tell Ourselves series. Each article looks at an everyday saying, what the data shows, and what it means if you tell stories with data. If you think I’ve missed something important, please let me know at kat@roguepenguin.co.nz.


Kat Greenbrook is a data storytelling consultant, author, and workshop facilitator based in Wellington, New Zealand. She is the founder of Rogue Penguin and the author of The Data Storyteller's Handbook.

bottom of page